• Recommend to a friend

Losing Out on Turning Customers into Fans – A Cleveland Browns Story


My soon to be seven year old son would like to go on a tour of the Cleveland Browns stadium for his birthday. This is a great idea for a number of reasons. First, we don’t have to clean the house. Second, the house won’t get trashed from all the kids coming over. And finally, it is a pretty unique idea and the kids will flat-out love it.

A very quick Google search revealed that they do have tours lasting about 40 minutes (perfect) for $5.00 per person (again perfect) but only Monday to Friday from 10-3. Not so perfect since we don’t home school, and even if we did, his friends would all still be in school those hours. There was a tiny clause at the bottom stating that they NEVER do tours on Sundays and occasionally on Saturdays.

So we emailed none-the-less. I asked for the Saturday closest to his birthday. Rejected. So I ask for any Saturday that month. Rejected. So I ask for Good Friday since the kids are off school that day. Rejected. I said I would have 40 people, trying to make it worth their time, I am flexible….but still REJECTED.

What is the value of having 40 kids fall in love with the Cleveland Browns and becoming life-long fans (in most cases, that’s exactly what would happen)? Priceless. But the Browns don’t see it that way.

The Carolina Panthers do offer full birthday parties with tours.  It’s no wonder this young franchise has grown its fan base so quickly.

Do you have any regulations or rules that are keeping customers from becoming true fanatics for your brand?

UPDATE: 2/19/10
We were able to secure a tour at 3pm on a Wednesday since the kid’s have early dismissal from school that day.  Not what we wanted, but at least it’s something.

This entry was posted in Case Studies and tagged . Bookmark the permalink. Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.
  • Join Over 25,000 of Your Peers!

    Get daily articles and news delivered to your email inbox and get CMI's exclusive ebook FREE. Attract and Retain Customers with Content Marketing.

    *
  • http://samuraiwriter.com/blog Mark McClure

    Wow! Perhaps they’re working on the anti-matter version of your book – “Avoid Contact. Lose Customers.”
    Just another digital scream in hyperspace…

  • http://rainbows.typepad.com/blog/2010/02/tomarceilcom-sent-you-a-link-to-content-of-interest.html Minding Gaps

    From Followers to Fans

    Here is a terrific blog from Joe Pulizzi on the importance and ease of converting followers to your fans. It involves his son’s would-be, wanna-be birthday party.

  • http://clickdocuments.com Ambal Balakrishnan

    Joe: Great post with an example that is “right-on”. Unfortunately, spreading the brand message seems to be siloed to just the branding-department in many businesses. Branding needs to be pervasive throughout every part of a business – sales, customer service, marketing and even the admin who sits in the front lobby.
    Happy Birthday to your 7 year old!

  • D. Haber

    That is yet another reason why Cleveland lost the original Browns, and why you should become a Ravens fan :)

  • http://blog.junta42.com Joe Pulizzi

    D…now I’m not sure I could handle that at all, but it is an idea.

  • http://www.jeffrutherford.com Jeff Rutherford

    Wow, that’s truly unbelievable. As you noted, not only would you have 40 people paying $5 bucks each, but they had the chance to build many lifelong fans.
    Last week, I took my 6-year old son to his first live sporting event, a UMass hockey game. He LOVED it. The fans cheering, yelling, the action on the ice, the snack bar, the mascot, etc.
    While you wouldn’t have been taking them to a game, I think sometimes adults, and harried sports marketing execs, underestimate the power of something like that – a tour of the stadium – through a young child’s eyes. They’ve never experienced it before, and it can be something they remember for many years.
    And, one final point, we’re not talking the Dallas Cowboys here. The Browns need every fan they can get. What a short-sighted mistake on their part.

  • http://blog.junta42.com Joe Pulizzi

    Hi Jeff…great example.
    I don’t get it either. My son is loving the colts and saints right now (for obvious reasons). Would love for him to be a Browns’ fan. Need a little help.

  • Brendon Clark

    I find it remarkable that an organisation would try so hard to alienate the very people it needs for ticket sales and merchandise and the like not to mention lifelong loyalty! How cool would it be if our favourite player turned up to say Hi even if it was just a prerecorded video link? Or I got a silly hat signed by the players which of course I”d treasure for years? Or the mascot turned up? Or they put my picture up on the screens come game time? Or any effort that might show they were even remotely interested in the people they want to come and adore them